Myakka City Homes for Sale

Myakka City Homes for Sale

Welcome to Myakka City, Florida—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Sarasota County. This charming rural community offers a unique blend of tranquility and accessibility, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a serene lifestyle without sacrificing modern conveniences. Surrounded by lush landscapes, Myakka City boasts an abundance of natural beauty, with sprawling ranches, scenic parks, and the stunning Myakka River, perfect for outdoor enthusiasts and nature lovers alike.

Myakka City is known for its friendly atmosphere and strong sense of community, where neighbors become friends and local events bring everyone together. Whether you’re exploring the picturesque Myakka River State Park or enjoying the local farmers’ market, you’ll find that life here flows at a more relaxed pace, allowing you to truly savor every moment.

When it comes to homes for sale in Myakka City, you’ll discover a diverse range of options that cater to various lifestyles and preferences. From charming single-family homes on spacious lots to beautiful equestrian estates, there’s something for everyone. Many properties feature stunning views, ample outdoor space, and modern amenities, making it easy to find your dream home in this idyllic setting.

With its close proximity to Sarasota, you can enjoy the best of both worlds—peaceful country living with easy access to urban conveniences. Experience the warmth and charm of Myakka City, where your dream home awaits. Explore our listings today and take the first step towards embracing a lifestyle filled with comfort, community, and natural beauty!

Newest Myakka City Homes for Sale

$1,875,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Acreage SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Once in a lifetime opportunity to own a custom ranch home located in beautiful Myakka City on over 12 acres, zoned agricultural with no hoa or deed restrictions. Private and fully fenced with an automatic equestrian front gate with call box. A double parcel with the house and barn on one side and the 25x40 shop with electric and water and 2 roll up doors and a side carport on the 2nd parcel. Pristine "HIGH and DRY" property with the most amazing lush, green pastures, the rear 4 are large enough to have multiple horses or cattle and has not been used for commercial crops so ready for grazing now. Designed for the serious equestrian, fully equipped 3 stall stable with feed and tack room and easy turn out to the back 4 pastures. Up front a 100x200 grass riding arena and another exercise paddock provide plenty of space for training and riding. Magnificent Live Oak trees grace the property and provide shade and many perfect spots to hang a swing or hammock. Inside this spacious farmhouse you will find many designer touches and updates including newer dual HVAC systems, newer water filtration system, newer septic drain field and a new well pump. Open concept living with 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms in this split plan design which also has the most incredible screened lanai with 1012 sq ft of outdoor covered living space. A lovely brick patio outside of the lanai extends the options for alfresco dining or soaking up the FLORIDA sunshine. Steps away the brand-new TIKI is perfect for relaxing in a hammock, and a great spot for grilling your fresh veggies just picked from the greenhouse. The 80x16 greenhouse has raised beds and is ready for vegetables, herbs and flowers. Gather your whole crew in the roomy kitchen with granite counters and wrap around breakfast bar. Ample natural light floods the formal dining room and has views of the private fishing pond with pink flowers. This home lives large and is ready for entertainment so host your family and friends at your own equestrian estate. The primary suite is a restful escape and has a spa like bathroom, sink into the oversized cast iron soaker tub after a day of adventures out on the farm. Find your peace at the edge of the county or create a mix of serene and income. Start a business, horse boarding/training/breeding, rv/boat storage, farming, automotive or any other ideas. The sky's the limit on this unrestricted double lot on over 12 acres. Easily build a 2nd home and create a family compound or have rental income. 2 chicken coops, and a shipping container with electric are also included. COUNTRY LIVING but still so close to amenities and shops and restaurants. Only 38 miles to the sugar sands of Anna Maria Island, 27 miles to UTC the mega shopping, dining and entertainment area. Nearby u pick farms such as Bella Blue Berry Farm and Hunsaders for fresh produce or grow your own in the fantastic greenhouse. Horse riding trails in Winding Creek, hiking access in Wingate Creek State Park, Manatee Gun and Archery Club, aviation training facilities, youth rodeo activities, and a new livestock auction house. Wonderful Western and English riding instruction facililities and minutes to Terra Nova Equestrian. Magical sunrises and sunsets daily. This property is truly a dream come true!

4610 403rd Street E, Myakka City
$2,500,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ Manatee River And Reservoir SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Bring the race cars, motor coaches, equipment, horses, or big ideas—this Lake Manatee property offers the space to make them possible. Situated on 7 private acres, the estate includes an approximately 5,000-square-foot, five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath home with a pool, whole-house generator, and water-filtration system. Two large detached shops provide outstanding flexibility for vehicle storage, trailers, machinery, workshop use, or a private automotive collection. One building includes a car lift and RV hookup, while the property’s location near the Freedom Factory makes it a natural fit for racing enthusiasts. Those seeking even more land may also purchase the adjoining 7-acre parcel separately, potentially creating a 14-acre compound with room for additional storage, fenced pasture, or equestrian improvements, subject to zoning and permitting. This is a property designed for buyers who need more than a beautiful home—they need room to live, work, store, and pursue their passions.

24525 Jennings Road, Myakka City
$1,200,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Magnolia Hill Subdivision SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
First Time Ever Offered For Sale! Welcome to a truly special property where privacy, functionality, and country charm come together on 5 picturesque acres in Myakka City. Custom built in 1994, this cherished family home has been lovingly maintained for more than 30 years and is now ready for its next chapter. With no HOA or CDD fees, you'll enjoy the freedom to truly make this property your own. Offering over 2,900 square feet, this spacious home features 3 bedrooms, an office, 3.5 bathrooms, and a thoughtfully designed floor plan with the primary suite conveniently located on the main level. Inside, you'll appreciate the soaring vaulted ceiling, a cozy wood-burning stove, fresh interior paint, brand-new carpet, newer luxury vinyl plank flooring, and a warm, inviting atmosphere that instantly feels like home. Step outside onto the welcoming country front porch, where you can relax with your morning coffee while overlooking majestic oak trees, a peaceful pond, and the beauty of rural Florida. Whether you're dreaming of horses, livestock, gardening, or simply enjoying wide-open spaces, this property offers endless possibilities. The outdoor amenities are equally impressive. A 30' x 36' powered workshop provides the perfect space for hobbies, projects, or equipment storage. The property also features a 16' x 36' covered outdoor kitchen and entertaining area, a second 16' x 30'' lean-to ideal for a high tower boat, RV, or additional storage, plus a 10' x 10' lean-to for even more versatility. A two-car garage with a convenient storage breezeway adds even more functionality to this exceptional property. Rarely does an opportunity arise to own a property that has been lovingly cared for by the same family since it was built. If you've been searching for acreage, privacy, room for your toys and animals, and a home filled with character, this is the one you've been waiting for.

28401 104th Dr E, Myakka City
$2,300,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Winding Creek SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Melissa’s Hope is a custom barndominium-style home built by Homes by Laura, Inc. and a 2026 Parade of Homes Winner. Designed to blend everyday comfort, equestrian functionality, and long-term flexibility, the main level features an open great room, kitchen, walk-in pantry, office, primary suite, two guest bedrooms, and an expansive porch. A drive-through breezeway, tack and feed room, and three stalls create a seamless connection between the home and outdoor living. Upstairs, a private two-bedroom apartment with a kitchen, living room, bathroom, and generous closet space offers flexibility for guests, extended family, or multigenerational living. Located on 5.86 acres in the wonderful, peaceful community of Winding Creek. Within the community, Winding Trails Ranch often hosts barrel races and other events. Far enough away from the crowded city life and only an hour drive down state road 64 to Anna Maria Island Beach. This lifestyle is one you will quickly fall in love with.

40916 11th Avenue East, Myakka City
$775,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Myakka Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Imagine your own 20 acre family farm/compound. Cleared pasture land with approximately 5 acres of low/wetland area. Property has perimeter barbed wire fencing with some cross fencing. Surrounded by thousands of acres of farm land so no neighbor's. Property has approximately 400 foot deep well with water available at various locations on the site along with a water purification system for the 3 bedroom 2 bath home. Septic system in place. Paddocks and other outbuildings on site but in need of repairs. Small pond on property. Create your own paradise with the 1700 sq foot home with your own updates. Located east of interstate 75 north of SR 70 on Wauchula Road. Set back a few hundred feet off the main road with gated private access.

8755 Wauchula Road, Myakka City
$1,650,000
3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ Sarasota Ranch Club SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Set on just over 10 acres in the gated Sarasota Ranch Club, this 2004 estate gives you privacy and room to spread out, with direct access to the community's horse trails. The single-story home runs 3,532 square feet with three bedrooms, four full baths, and a dedicated media room. Cathedral ceilings and an open floor plan run throughout, and a split-bedroom layout keeps the primary suite on the main level, where the spa-style bath has dual vanities, a soaking tub, and a walk-in shower. Each additional bedroom has its own en-suite bath. The kitchen opens to the family room, with stone counters throughout and a fireplace anchoring the main living space. Outside, manicured grounds and a private courtyard surround the home, and a five-car garage handles vehicles and equipment. Close to Sarasota conveniences while still feeling a world away, this is acreage living with the finishes to match.

15986 Cutting Horse Trail, Myakka City
$2,900,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Acreage SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
UNMATCHED OPPORTUNITY | A PRIVATE ESTATE COMPOUND WITH EXCLUSIVE SOLETA ACCESS Opportunities like this are exceptionally rare and impossible to duplicate. Set on more than 9 private acres adjacent to the highly anticipated Soleta Golf & Country Club, this extraordinary estate offers something no other property can: exclusive access directly into Soleta while remaining entirely outside of the community's restrictions, rules, and limitations. Tucked behind mature oaks and towering pines, this secluded estate compound provides the ultimate blend of privacy, freedom, and luxury. Through a private entrance located between future Soleta homesites 51 and 52 or of your choosing, owners enjoy direct access to one of Florida's most exciting new country club communities while maintaining complete control of their own property. Unlike homes located within the gates of Soleta, this estate is free from HOA oversight, builder requirements, architectural restrictions, and ancillary building limitations. Create the lifestyle you envision with room for guest houses, equestrian facilities, workshops, collector garages, recreational amenities, or future expansion opportunities. For golf enthusiasts, the included Soleta membership unlocks access to a world-class lifestyle centered around a meticulously designed 18-hole USGA Championship Golf Course by Nick Price and an impressive 30-acre practice facility designed by David Leadbetter. Beyond golf, Soleta's 537-acre master-planned community embraces the natural beauty of the Myakka River, featuring a 140-acre riverfront preserve with nature trails, biking paths, fishing, canoeing, and outdoor recreation. Residents enjoy access to tennis and pickleball courts, a state-of-the-art fitness center, luxury spa facilities, boutique shopping, a lagoon-style pool with splash pad, multiple dining venues, and a vibrant social calendar. For those seeking the ultimate private retreat, the property's expansive acreage even offers the flexibility to accommodate a private helicopter landing area, creating unparalleled convenience for travel and entertaining. This is more than a homesite. It is a legacy estate, a private compound, and a once-in-a-generation opportunity to enjoy country club luxury without sacrificing freedom, privacy, or possibility. Photo 2 illustrates the approximate property boundaries in blue and Soleta boundaries in green as well as identifies the planned location of the private gated access into Soleta in red.

34452 Singletary Rd, Myakka City
$629,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Myakka Sub SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Rare opportunity to own a private 6.2-acre agricultural zoned property offering a blend of country living and modern comfort. Bring your horses, donkeys, cows, chickens and all the animals you’ve dreamed of. This fully fenced property is ready for your farm, homestead or family compound. The beautifully updated home features a functional split bedroom floor plan and an open-concept kitchen and has been meticulously maintained. Major updates include a new roof (2025) and a new air-conditioning system (2025), providing peace of mind for years to come. Properties like this are becoming increasingly difficult to find in this desirable area. Enjoy the tranquility and privacy of rural living while benefiting from exciting future growth nearby, including planned golf courses and an equestrian center just down the road. Whether you’re looking for room to roam, space for animals or a peaceful retreat for the entire family, this exceptional property offers endless possibilities. Move right in and start enjoying the lifestyle you’ve always wanted.

13105 Mj Road, Myakka City
$1,140,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Winding Creek SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Luxury, privacy, & nearly 6 FENCED ACRES come together in one extraordinary custom-built Mark Cahill estate in Myakka City. Behind the PRIVATE CODED MOTORIZED ENTRY GATE, you'll discover the freedom, space, & lifestyle today's buyers are searching for. Based on current land & construction costs, recreating a comparable estate like this today could approach $2 MILLION, making this an exceptional opportunity to own a luxury country property without the wait, uncertainty, or rising costs of new construction. Inside, soaring ceilings, 8-FOOT DOORS, crown molding with accent lighting, a dramatic double tray ceiling, elegant chandeliers, & ALL TILE FLOORING create an impressive yet welcoming atmosphere. Built-in shelving anchors the living room, while an aquarium window frames peaceful views of the pool from the main living areas. The flexible floor plan offers 4 BEDROOMS, 3 BATHS, formal living & dining rooms, a dedicated office, & an oversized kitchen with breakfast bar & island. Step outside to your own private retreat featuring a SALTWATER PebbleTec pool with SOLAR HEAT, a RESISTANCE SWIM SYSTEM for year-round exercise, winter safety cover, cool deck, RETRACTABLE MOTORIZED AWNING, sunshade, pool bath access, outdoor shower, & a fenced dog run—all designed for entertaining, relaxing, & enjoying Florida's outdoor lifestyle. Need room for hobbies, horses, recreational vehicles, or a home-based business? The 900 SQ FT WORKSHOP is a standout feature, offering WATER, POWER, approximately half under AIR CONDITIONING, pass-through access, & attached COVERED PARKING for boats, trailers, or equipment. The home also includes an oversized 3-CAR GARAGE. Built with durability, efficiency, & peace of mind in mind, this home features HURRICANE-IMPACT WINDOWS & GARAGE DOORS, ICYNENE INSULATION, an OWNED 9.5 kW SOLAR SYSTEM, GENERAC GENERATOR with buried 250-GALLON PROPANE TANK, a security system with sensors on all doors & windows, & a BRAND-NEW (2026) $30,000 WELL SYSTEM with sulfur filtration & chlorinated pipes. The barrel tile roof adds timeless curb appeal, & the property has experienced no flooding or hurricane damage. Winding Creek offers a peaceful country setting with a private community park, lakefront picnic area, riding opportunities, community events, & LOW HOA FEES of just $800 per year. Nearby boating, parks, nature preserves, bow hunting, & the local motorsports facility provide endless opportunities for outdoor recreation. Be sure to explore the Matterport 3D Tour & review the complete Features Sheet to discover the many additional upgrades & amenities this remarkable estate has to offer. Schedule your private showing today & discover why this extraordinary property represents an exceptional opportunity to own a luxury estate that's difficult to replicate at today's construction costs.

1210 408th Court E, Myakka City
$749,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Mossy Hammock SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
NOW OFFERED $45K BELOW THE PREVIOUS LIST PRICE! This price improvement leaves room for you to add your own finishes, design touches and modern updates to create the home you've always envisioned. Where Privacy Is Permanent – A Rare 5.18-Acre Estate in Myakka City. Some properties simply cannot be recreated. Welcome to one of Myakka City's most private estate properties, where 5.18 beautiful acres meet permanently protected conservation land, creating a setting that offers peace, privacy, and natural beauty that is increasingly rare in Southwest Florida. Nestled at the end of a quiet cul de sac, this beautifully maintained concrete block home is surrounded by majestic oak trees, abundant wildlife, and hundreds of acres of protected conservation land, ensuring the breathtaking views and unmatched privacy will remain for generations to come. Adding to the property's unique character is a natural, flowing creek along the southern boundary that feeds into Mossy Island Slough. A private clearing with a picnic table has been thoughtfully created along the creek, offering a peaceful retreat where you can relax beneath the trees, enjoy your morning coffee, read a book, or simply listen to the gentle sounds of flowing water. It's a hidden sanctuary that makes this property unlike any other. Inside, the home offers comfortable living spaces filled with natural light and picturesque views of the surrounding landscape. Whether you're entertaining family and friends or enjoying a quiet evening on the porch, every window reminds you that you've found a truly special place. Recent improvements include a new roof (2022), new water heater (2025), and generator-ready wiring, providing confidence and peace of mind for years to come. Beyond the home itself, there is room to create the lifestyle you've always imagined horses, gardens, a workshop, recreational vehicles, or simply wide-open space to enjoy. The combination of usable acreage, mature trees, a peaceful creek, protected conservation land, and an end of the road location creates a property that is exceptionally difficult to duplicate. Located just a short drive from Lakewood Ranch, Sarasota, and Gulf Coast beaches, you'll enjoy the convenience of nearby amenities while coming home to the quiet beauty of Old Florida. This is more than a home, it's a place to reconnect with nature, enjoy lasting privacy, and create memories for years to come. Opportunities to own a property with this combination of natural beauty, protected surroundings, and thoughtful improvements are truly rare.

14705 Mossy Hammock Lane, Myakka City
$479,995
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Na SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
Escape to the peaceful lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of at 464 Logue Rd. Nestled on 5+ beautiful acres in the countryside, this charming stilt home with underground utilities offers the perfect blend of privacy, space, and convenience—exactly what today’s buyers have been searching for. Enjoy serene country living with room to roam, while still being just a short drive to major roads, shopping, dining, and everyday essentials. Located only steps away from southern horse/biking and hunting access gate of one of the top state protected preserves. Duette Preserve boasts 21,000 acres with deer, hog, coyote, turkey and quail hunting with seasonal passes. Unlimited horse back riding, bike riding and hiking for small pass fee. Headwaters of both the Manatee and Myakka River's are located within the preserve. This is nature's paradise you've been waiting for! Beneath the home, you’ll find abundant covered parking (1145sq ft) and storage space ideal for vehicles, boats, equipment, or creating the ultimate outdoor entertaining area. Inside, the home has been refreshed and updated with new kitchen & bathroom quartz counters and sink, new flooring, new paint, a new METAL roof in 2025, new HVAC in 2021 and new commercial pressure bladder tank on the well in 2025. What's not to love about the word "NEW"?! Whether you’ve been searching for acreage, a move-in ready home, or the quiet country lifestyle without sacrificing convenience, this property checks all the boxes. Come experience the charm, space, and possibilities of this Myakka City gem.

464 Logue Road, Myakka City
$624,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Goldens SubDv. ⋅ 34251 Zip Code
No HOA, no CDD, and complete freedom on a spacious 0.53-acre lot in Myakka City! This estate-style residence offers no deed restrictions with ample room for on-site RV, boat, or trailer storage. The property features a brand-new roof installed in 2025 and a high-efficiency 17 SEER Trane HVAC system replaced in 2021, ensuring the primary structural elements are optimized for long-term performance. Strategically positioned in Flood Zone X with an intentionally raised base elevation, the home is engineered for superior drainage and sits prominently on a high-percolation lot with no flood insurance required. Freshly curated with designer paint inside and out, the property serves as a secure sanctuary fully enclosed by a 2024 privacy fence and professional-grade invisible pet fencing. The beautifully designed 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom layout plus a dedicated closed-off office/den features a central open-concept living area and a spacious owner's suite with direct access to the screened lanai and saltwater pool. Thoughtful upgrades include an updated water filtration system with under-sink reverse osmosis drinking water, upgraded ceiling fans and light fixtures, an outdoor fire pit, custom garage storage shelving, and a dedicated exterior-access pool bath for guests. A private well and high-capacity septic system offer total operational autonomy and reduced monthly utility costs. As a peaceful country escape, the property remains exceptionally well-located just a short drive from the upscale shopping, dining, and entertainment of Lakewood Ranch and UTC, as well as the world-renowned Gulf beaches of Bradenton and Sarasota. Own what’s real!

26013 81st Drive E, Myakka City
Start Your Search